CO129-273 - Governor Sir Robinson & Others - 1896 [10-12] — Page 40

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

and the Policeman, who has to remit at market rate of exchange, could get $150 for $78, when the exchange was 1921⁄2 to $100

when 15597/95.

Therefore the Policeman was as the Soldier.

But when this despatch was written the Indian exchange rate had fallen at Haiphong to R-178 per $100 and since then (judging from the exchanges on London) I gather that it must have fallen to about $170. Hence the 3rd Class Constable at Hongking (in the absence of Family Remittance privilege) were no better off than the Soldier, be rather worse off, and there was some reason for giving him the Family remittance privilege, which the Governor has given;

There was but I doubt if there sufficient reason, considering chance of promotion from 3rd Class to 2nd Class Constables, i.e. from $150 a year to $168 + $186 a year which prospects (I believe) are not open to the Soldier.

In the case of the Sikh police it appear from Straits, the Leg. Council and the Govt of Straits objected vide 20958/95 to giving compensation, as it would open the door to many similar claims there being numerous natives of India in the service of the Colony.

(We had a memorial on the subject from Indians in the N. States which we refused to accede to); and it is most unfortunate that the Governing Mayor has granted this family remittance privilege (which is only another form of Exchange compensation), and in view of the despatch No. 5018 (Straits) which implied that he should confer with the Governor of the Straits as well as with the Govt of H.K. with a view to making the conditions of service nearly alike in the two Colonies & in the Civil & Military forces, I don't think he ought to have made this change without first getting approval of the Govt.

State seeing that it has the effect of making a still wider gap between the pay of the Straits & H.K. Police. (At the Straits the Sikh Constables only get from $108 to $132, compared with $186-$150-$168 here).

Such action will, I fear, make it impossible to adhere to any sort of exchange compensation policy at the Straits or refusing any compensation to natives of India.

Page 196

...

XCR(85)72

GR1178/1922/32(III)

Edit History

2026-05-28 00:20:24 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
and the Policeman, who has to remit at market rate of exchange, could get $150 for $78, when the exchange was 1921⁄2 to $100 when 15597/95. Therefore the Policeman was as the Soldier. But when this despatch was written the Indian exchange rate had fallen at Haiphong to R-178 per $100 and since then (judging from the exchanges on London) I gather that it must have fallen to about $170. Hence the 3rd Class Constable at Hongking (in the absence of Family Remittance privilege) were no better off than the Soldier, be rather worse off, and there was some reason for giving him the Family remittance privilege, which the Governor has given; There was but I doubt if there sufficient reason, considering chance of promotion from 3rd Class to 2nd Class Constables, i.e. from $150 a year to $168 + $186 a year which prospects (I believe) are not open to the Soldier. In the case of the Sikh police it appear from Straits, the Leg. Council and the Govt of Straits objected vide 20958/95 to giving compensation, as it would open the door to many similar claims there being numerous natives of India in the service of the Colony. (We had a memorial on the subject from Indians in the N. States which we refused to accede to); and it is most unfortunate that the Governing Mayor has granted this family remittance privilege (which is only another form of Exchange compensation), and in view of the despatch No. 5018 (Straits) which implied that he should confer with the Governor of the Straits as well as with the Govt of H.K. with a view to making the conditions of service nearly alike in the two Colonies & in the Civil & Military forces, I don't think he ought to have made this change without first getting approval of the Govt. State seeing that it has the effect of making a still wider gap between the pay of the Straits & H.K. Police. (At the Straits the Sikh Constables only get from $108 to $132, compared with $186-$150-$168 here). Such action will, I fear, make it impossible to adhere to any sort of exchange compensation policy at the Straits or refusing any compensation to natives of India. Page 196 ... XCR(85)72 GR1178/1922/32(III)
Baseline (Original)
and the Policeman, who has to remit at market rate of exchange, could get R=150 for $78, when the exchange W=1921⁄2 to # 100 when 15597/95. quiti was g Therefor the Policeman was as the Soldier. But when this desp was written way will off written the Indian exchange rate had fallen at Haughing to R-178 per $100 and since then / pedzing from the exchanges es on Landen) I gather that it must have allen to about W-170. Hence the 3rd Class Constable at then Hongking / in the absence of Family Remittance privilege) were no off than the Soldier, be rather worse and there was some reason for giving Therefin him the Jamil remittance privilege, which the fovemer has given; There was but I doubt if there sufficient the prospects of reasm, considering Clan to quillan promotion from 3rd Clan to 2 سلام Fit Class (mustables, i. s. from /$150 a gear to $$168 + $186 a year which prospects (Ibelieve) are not Open to the Soldier. In the case of ERT appear from When newspaper The Straits, the Leg. Council and the Lee of Stat objected see the Sikh police exchange 20958/95 to giving compensation, as it would open the (" 566171 X. It was not made quite elem harhafer an we did not door to many similar claims there being numerous natives India in the service of the Joling O the Nation States (we had memorial on the subject from Indians win the N. Stater which we refused to 38 accede to ] ; and it is most unfortunate that the fovering Many has granted this famil remittance privilege (which is only another form of Exchange compensation), and in view of the desk & on < 5018 (Thaits) which implied that 196 he should confer with the foverer all that of the Straits tall the Jo. of had passed 2 well as with the the conditions of service. between 6.0. B.O.C.H Kary with a view to ** Stunit the subject getting nearly alike in the annemore nearly Ro two folmies & in the Curl & Military faces, I don't think he might to have made bat, without change off his own first getting approval of the Lee. State _ seeing that it has then Effect of making a still wider sap between the pay of than Straits &#Kay Police. (At the Thaits Fin the M. States the Sikle Constables only get from 18108 to $132, compared with 186150 57818691 Hery) Sin W. Robusais action will I fear make it unpossible to ather of policy at the Straits sort of exchange to refusing any compensation to natives ta
2026-05-28 00:20:24 · Baseline
View content

and the Policeman, who has to remit at market rate of exchange, could get R=150 for $78, when the exchange

W=1921⁄2 to # 100

when 15597/95. quiti

was g

Therefor

the Policeman was as the Soldier.

But when this desp

was written

way

will off

written

the Indian exchange rate had fallen at Haughing to R-178 per $100 and since then / pedzing from the exchanges

es on Landen) I gather that it must have allen to about W-170. Hence the 3rd Class Constable at

then

Hongking / in the absence of Family Remittance privilege) were no

off than the Soldier,

be rather worse

and there was some reason

for giving

Therefin

him the Jamil remittance

privilege, which the fovemer has given;

There was

but I doubt if there

sufficient the prospects of

reasm, considering Clan to quillan promotion from 3rd Clan to 2

سلام

Fit Class (mustables, i. s. from /$150 a gear to $$168 + $186 a year which prospects (Ibelieve) are not Open to the Soldier.

In the case

of

ERT

appear from When newspaper

The Straits, the Leg. Council and the Lee of Stat objected see

the Sikh police exchange 20958/95 to giving compensation, as it would open the

("

566171

X. It was not made quite elem harhafer

an we did not

door to many similar claims

there being

numerous natives

India in the service of the Joling

O the Nation States (we had

memorial on the subject from Indians win the N. Stater which we

refused to

38

accede to ] ; and it is most unfortunate that the fovering Many has granted this famil remittance privilege (which is only another form of Exchange compensation), and in view of the desk & on

<

5018 (Thaits) which implied that

196

he should confer with the foverer all that of the Straits

tall the Jo. of

had passed

2

well as with the

the conditions of service. between 6.0. B.O.C.H Kary with a view to

**

Stunit the subject

getting

nearly alike in the

annemore nearly

Ro

two folmies & in the Curl & Military faces, I don't think he might to have made

bat, without change off his own first getting approval of the Lee.

State _ seeing that it has then Effect of making a still wider sap between the pay of than Straits &#Kay Police. (At the Thaits Fin the M. States the Sikle Constables only get from 18108 to $132,

compared with 186150

57818691

Hery)

Sin W. Robusais action will I fear make it unpossible to ather

of policy at the Straits

sort of exchange

to

refusing any

compensation to natives

ta

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.